Skip to content

CEO swap: How landscaping leaders traded companies for three days

Jeff Margulies (center) Good Earth Landscaping, took a group photo with his new team of three days, Strathmeyer Landscape. (Photo: McFarlin Stanford)
Jeff Margulies (center) Good Earth Landscaping, took a group photo with his new team of three days, Strathmeyer Landscape. (Photo: McFarlin Stanford)

It isn’t uncommon for lawn care and landscape companies to open their doors to their fellow industry professionals. Earlier this year, more than a thousand people traveled to Dallas to attend GROW! where Complete Landsculpture allowed visitors to go station to station, learning the ins and outs of their business. Grunder Landscaping Co. in Dayton, Ohio, regularly opens its doors to visitors. Just last month, Envisor Consulting brought a group to Omaha, Neb., to see how Greenhall Commercial Landscapes services its clients.

But here’s something new, bold and different: what about making an arrangement so two CEOs could swap places with each other, for three days?

That’s what happened earlier this year when 24 CEOs traded places with each other. Boston to San Antonio; Rochester, N.Y. to Holland, Mich.; Baton Rouge, La., to Charleston, S.C. — two CEOs of similarly sized companies traded places with each other to learn and see how another company is operating, from the inside. 

Bakker goes on a site visit while in New York. (Photo: McFarlin Stanford)
Bakker goes on a site visit while in New York. (Photo: McFarlin Stanford)

Accountability partners, trade jobs

Arranged by industry consultants McFarlin Stanford and The Grow Group, the CEO swap is called ACE 2.0 and is designed for long-tenured ACE Peer Group members. The two people making the swap already know each other well: They’re “accountability partners” within their own peer groups and have regular in-person meetings and phone calls to discuss their businesses. 

The idea came from James Cali, founding principal of McFarlin Stanford. Before co-founding McFarlin Stanford, Cali worked for FedEx. It was a regular practice at FedEx to swap branch managers between underperforming and top-performing store locations. The results were often eye-opening and resulted in improved performance for both stores and branch managers.

Jason New, McFarlin Stanford, surprised Tony Distefano, Angelo’s Landscape Group, on his trip to GrandScapes in Charleston, S.C. (Photo: Angelo’s Landscape)
Jason New, McFarlin Stanford, surprised Tony Distefano, Angelo’s Landscape Group, on his trip to GrandScapes in Charleston, S.C. (Photo: Angelo’s Landscape)

Proposed to a select group of CEOs in the ACE Peer Group system, the program made its debut in March of this year. There was certainly a sense of trepidation — even resistance — from the CEOs.

When Cali and Vince Torchia, vice president, The Grow Group, first told the members of ACE 2.0 that this swap was on their curriculum, they weren’t thrilled with the idea. 

“Originally, they were completely against it. They were nervously like, ‘Why would we do this? I don’t want to go run another partner’s company,’” Torchia says. “When we got that feedback with their nerves and apprehension, we kind of knew we were onto something.” 

Road trip!

The CEO swap did come with specific instructions, an agenda and even provided questions to be asked in advance. And there was one more safety net the CEOs weren’t aware of: At each swap, a representative from McFarlin Stanford or The Grow Group would make an appearance to help ease the nerves.

Other than those tools, it was up to the visiting CEO to step up and lead a new company for three days. The actual CEO couldn’t stop to clarify a point, or a process. It was a road trip to join a new home team.

“For the CEO swap, there was no crutch,” Torchia says. “You are literally running the meeting from the time you get there until the time you leave. You can’t be on your phone — you have to bring it.”

What happened when Greg Cole of Cole Landscaping first arrived to Summit Landscape outside San Antonio? He was greeted with hugs and his own customized Summit employee work shirt.

Cole takes a look around the shop at Summit. (Photo: LM staff)
Cole takes a look around the shop at Summit. (Photo: LM staff)

Cole admits the moment he walked through the Summit door, the nerves hit.

“I don’t get nervous too often, but I was a little nervous,” Cole says. “This is very different. I felt like I was on a game show, almost. I was like, ‘Is someone filming this thing?’”

Once the nerves settled down, it was time for business. The Summit team gave Cole an overview of their company, and a thorough conversation about what was working great and what could be improved upon ensued. Cole was a set of fresh eyes and ears for the Summit team to talk with while their CEO, Jonathan Peterson, was 2,000 miles away.

“At first, it was scary because obviously I don’t know these people. They don’t know my people,” Cole says. “It’s Texas and Boston — two totally different worlds. I didn’t know how that would play out. But I knew this was a great idea. Jonathan and I, we have the same struggles.”

Cole’s biggest takeaway was the outstanding culture at Summit: the energy, the team investment, the cheeseburger cookout at the end of the day. One detail that really caught his eye: a sound system in the shop that was cranked up loud during the morning stretch and flex and again as crews returned in the afternoon. A similar setup is now installed at Cole Landscaping’s shop.

For Peterson, his visit to Boston was also eye-opening. While Cole is a process-driven operator, Peterson is more of a people person. Seeing how Cole and Cole Landscape uses data and production software gave him an inside look at why Cole is successful. It’s something he plans on bringing back to Summit.

“What’s crazy is how much of what I saw in his company I couldn’t see in my own, and vice versa,” Peterson says.

Jeff Margulies, Good Earth Landscaping and Maintenance, Aspen, Colo., talks to the team at Strathmeyer Landscape, Dover, Pa. (Photo: LM staff)
Jeff Margulies, Good Earth Landscaping and Maintenance, Aspen, Colo., talks to the team at Strathmeyer Landscape, Dover, Pa. (Photo: LM staff)

Know your role

There were bound to be some surprises with a new face in all the offices. There was one employee who cried when the topic of delegation came up. Another employee shared an idea they’d been quietly developing with the visiting CEO as a test to see how it might go with his own CEO.

While opening the door to a visiting CEO was at first rebuffed, once it happened, the opportunity it created became clear. 

“The only reason you can be nervous about opening up your business is if it’s something you know you should already be working on,” Peterson says. “If it is, this should fire you up to fix it. If it’s not, you need someone else to see it for you.”

When it came time for Cole to leave for Texas, his employees wanted to know what he hoped they’d say to Peterson, their new CEO for a few days. He agreed to have a meeting to discuss the agenda and what would happen, but he refused to tell them what he wanted them to say.

“I told them, ‘Know your role.’ That’s all I said,” Cole says. “And they said, ‘Well, what’s my role?’ I told them, you know your role, you know all that stuff. That’s how I left it — I wanted this to be raw.”

Jason New, founding principal of McFarlin Stanford, traveled to San Antonio to welcome Cole to Summit on day one of the CEO swap. He mostly served as a silent observer but also helped out with the conversation from time to time.

“Some of the things that came up is, it’s OK for the team to be vulnerable,” New says. “We as owners are comfortable in that scenario. Like Greg told his employees — know your role, be yourself and go … talk about whatever you need to talk about. Ultimately it helps the team. Talk about things that will move the company forward.”

Ryan, Jake and Jim Malone of Malone’s Landscape in Seattle made the trip to Coastal Greenery in Georgia. (Photo: McFarlin Stanford)
Ryan, Jake and Jim Malone of Malone’s Landscape in Seattle made the trip to Coastal Greenery in Georgia. (Photo: McFarlin Stanford)

Trading trucks

On the final day of the CEO swap, the visiting CEO delivered an assessment directly to the host team with no owner in the room to soften the message. For Tony Distefano, owner and president of Angelo’s Landscape Group, Baton Rouge, La., this was his opportunity to discuss what he saw during his visit to GrandScapes in Charleston, S.C. Before he held that meeting, he called Adam Dukes, the CEO of GrandScapes and his accountability partner, to discuss that conversation.

“I wanted to be careful not to be overstepping our message to the group, and he was OK with everything I wanted to say,” Distefano says. “But I didn’t hold back. I told them there were some wonderful things about their team and company, but there’s also some low-hanging fruit for them to get on right away. They were very receptive.”

Upon returning home, the CEOs followed up with each other while everything was fresh to give each other a debrief of the experience. Who laughed, who cried and maybe a suggestion to talk to the one employee about that idea he’s been holding on to.

Wrapping up day one at Summit Landscape are New, Marie Grove, finance manager, Cole and Jason Dailey, yard manager. (Photo: LM staff)
Wrapping up day one at Summit Landscape are New, Marie Grove, finance manager, Cole and Jason Dailey, yard manager. (Photo: LM staff)

According to Cali, the CEO swap wasn’t just a fun experiment, but a proven way to expose blind spots within a company. When they did the swap at FedEx, Cali adds, the struggling branch always took a big step up in production.

He adds that it wasn’t easy getting the ACE 2.0 members to embrace the CEO swap, but once they did, the results were positive.

“I was blown away by the feedback afterwards. When we announced it, we had 50 percent of the room saying, ‘What are we doing?’ and the other half really excited. As the event got nearer, the mood from both sides seemed to escalate,” Cali says. “After the event finished, even the naysayers were impressed. We had one attendee implement the swap among his three branches.”

Distefano says he was one of the naysayers who didn’t want to participate in the swap. Now that he experienced it, he’s glad he did it and adds he brought multiple ideas to Angelo’s that he picked up in his time at GrandScapes. 

The travel was seamless, he adds, so much so that Distefano and Dukes not only traded offices but also trucks — they both hid keys in their work boots and texted each other the location of their trucks at the airport.

“Adam and I flew at the same time. I left my vehicle for him, he left his for me,” Distefano says. “I came rolling up in Adam’s truck, parking in Adam’s spot, and I put my bag in Adam’s office. They’re looking at me like, ‘OK, this guy’s wearing one of our shirts.’ They were a little timid at first, but once they understood I was there for their benefit, they started opening up and sharing the good, the bad, the ugly. He’s got a fantastic team and were receptive. It was a great experience.”

Cali says the CEO swap will return in 2027 with a new group of ACE participants. Some tweaks will be made to the program, but one thing will not change: the trust it takes to pull the whole thing off.

“The most valuable growth happens when trust runs deep enough that you can hand the keys to your shop to someone and say, ‘It’s all yours, let me know how it goes,’” Cali says. 

The keys to the shop and also, apparently, the keys to your truck. 

Editor’s note: Paul Myers, McFarlin Stanford, contributed to this story.

Distefano, Angelo’s Landscape Group, visits with the team at GrandScapes in Charleston, S.C. “(GrandScapes) has a fantastic team and were receptive,” Distefano says. (Photo: Angelo’s Landscape Group)
Distefano, Angelo’s Landscape Group, visits with the team at GrandScapes in Charleston, S.C. “(GrandScapes) has a fantastic team and were receptive,” Distefano says. (Photo: Angelo’s Landscape Group)
Photo: Seth Jones

Seth Jones

Seth Jones is the editorial director of Landscape Management, and the editor-in-chief of Golfdom and Athletic Turf magazines. A graduate of Kansas University’s William Allen White School of Journalism and Mass Communications, Seth was voted best columnist in the industry in 2014, 2018 and 2023 by the Turf & Ornamental Communicators Association. He has more than 23 years of experience in the golf and turf industries and has traveled the world seeking great stories.

To top